Poochat Deen Dayal ko dhaam, batawat aapno naam Sudama! Billu Barber review

billu_barber_3b

Billu Barber is the third retelling of a modernized Krishna Sudama story.  Since no hairdressers protested in the USA, I did get to see Billu Barber in its entirety with no words hidden, muted or bleeped!  After the highly successful Malayalam version, we had a failed Tamil version, and now Pridarshan gives us the tale in Hindi.  Why so many versions of the same story?  Because the world has changed, and the characters and morals of the story must needs be reworked for modern times.

still2

Billu (Irrfan Kahn) plies his marginal barber trade in the small hamlet of Budbuda, Uttar Pradesh.  In the opening scenes a Raj transport bus is shown to be going from Ghazipur to Budbuda!   Billu’s shop is barely running and his family in dire straits.  Then Budbuda is turned upside down by the arrival of a filming crew with the reigning superstar Sahir Khan (Shahrukh Khan).  The village finds out that Billu is a childhood friend of Sahir and suddenly Billu’s lot is much improved, only to be cast back into the doldrums when he is unable to show any proof of knowing the star.  In this tale, as in the divine one, in the end the friendship is acknowledged and Billu is redeemed in the eyes of his family and friends.

still28

The tale is simple and linear, and told without much fuss or diversions.  The entertainment quotient comes from the ensemble cast that makes up Billu’s fellow Budbuda dwellers – the poet “laureate” (Rajpal Yadav), the neighbor (Asrani), and local moneylender (Om Puri) and his henchmen, and his rival “hairdresser”!  And of course the star comes with his own accoutrement of item numbers with a trio of beauties, Deepika, Kareena and Priyanka.  The 4th beauty, Lara Dutta, is the muted Bindiya, Billu’s wife and mother of his two kids.  The films travels through some placid and some turbulent waters of Budbuda life, interspersed with encounters between the villagers and Sahir.  The comic moments are vintage Priyan and remind one of the Hera Pheri days more than the recent Priyan films.  The other entertainment is by way of a nonsensical film of brothers separated, one is an intergalactic traveler and the other lives in a village!  In an insane twist the quest to find the brother is set in a mela – thus turning the classic bichadna scene into a possible milna.  And the beeping locket that was supposedly put around each neck is the cause of much hilarity.  The simplicity of village life, a goat, a chulha with roti cooking on it, washing clothes at the river, school-children with oiled hair in plaits, bullock carts, bicycles and the constant need to know about neighbor’s affairs is put together like a piece of art by Sabu Cyril and framed beautifully by Manikandan’s lens.

The performances by the main cast are quite even, others sometimes loudly comic and a bit loutish, especially when it comes to the villagers.  Irrfan IS Billu.  He is brilliant as the hard working, wry, and dry humored man hard-pressed to make ends meet, and terrified of finding out that Sahir does not remember him.  His “conversation” with Sahir in the phone booth is a classic.  Lara is competent as the village woman, a bit youthful but still down-to-earth and human in craving attention.  Shahrukh gives an even performance as a larger than life star – all the way from the on-stage rockstar persona (Ae Aa Oo), to the man who, in a flash, reveals his vulnerabilities as he reminisces about his long lost friend.   The item girls are all gorgeous looking, but Kareena and the setting and choreography of Marjaani steal the show.  Deepika has equal time in the intergalactic Love Mera Hit Hit, while Priyanka does part of the lunge version of Khudaya Khair.  The reality of these songs is apparent in the film – as none is part of the narrative, and they are either parts of Sahir’s films, or being shot in front of the villagers.  Some trimming of these (as was done with Priyanka’s song) would have helped shorten the film and made it better paced.

So what is this new take on the Krishna Sudama story?  By making a superstar take on a god-like role (and this was the intent right from the original Malayalam version) is the author of the story telling us that we have now created new icons?  Perhaps a villager putting a tika on the forehead of a star photo and praying to it, only pushes the idea further.  That is a depressing thought indeed.  In Sudama Charit Narottam Das tells us:

Dekhi Sudama ki deen dasha, karuna kari ke Karuna Nidhi roye
Paani parat ko haath chuyo nahin, nainan ke jal so pag dhoye.

To balance deifying of stars out, this “Krishna” seeks out Sudama, and does not promise or bestow wealth on him, but by merely wistfully wishing to remember those good times, tells him they are in essence equals.

The film has its heart in the right place and is worth a watch!  3.5/5

Advertisements

51 Responses

  1. Great review Pakhi . will see it in a day or two .

  2. If it was Katrina in place of Lara, Hardik would have seen FDFS 😉

  3. True rks, and in fact Kareena is also responsible for the delay by a couple of days!

  4. Even I am little averse to anorexic Kareena.

  5. Nice review Pakhi

  6. Kareena was a healthy glowing beauty in Billu! No size zero was in evidence – stop it you haters! 🙂

  7. Kareena is gorgeous, ethereal, stunning! She rules in the gorgeouness department any day, any film!

  8. If Kareena is Healthy and glowing then Nagma, Kajol or Ayesha Takia are … ?

  9. oh loook another gorgeous just showed up in my avi 😀

  10. rks how can you even compare a diva like Kareena with the plane janes like kajol and takia? 😮

  11. And who is Nagma? LOL

  12. Gore gore mukhde pe kaala kaala chashma or aakhir tumhe aana hai zara der lagegi 😀 Youtube 😛 Now she’s a southie star I think.

  13. Was she in King Uncle?

  14. Nagma, 90s Feroz Khan movie..Yalgaar…”Aakhir Tumhe Aana hai” 🙂

    Dim – Nazar Nazar ka pharak hai 🙂

  15. RKS – sure nazar nazar ka farak hai. But watching Kareena in a beautifully staged song was something else.

  16. http://www.rediff.com/entertai/1998/dec/03nag.htm

  17. consensus rks 😛 Majority has the say 😀

  18. And it is such a huge majority!

  19. Quorum hi nahi hai to majority ki naat hi kahan?

  20. Hahaha! Arre kal tak to koi insaan nahin dikhta thaa door door tak! Ab itne log hain aur quorum nahin?

  21. dekho dekho kaun hai idhar . rks where r u man . i will not watch a katrina movie for 6 months but come on sb yaar . diff name se hi sahi .

  22. Hahaha hardy – now you know where to find RKS! Yahan hai yahan hai yahan hai yahan!!!

  23. Thanks Arun!

  24. I found this blog via NG. Great review, keep up the good work.

  25. Thanks Meenu – hope to see you back.

  26. Pakhi – good review. Thanks for posting.

  27. Good review !! Thanks Pakhiji !!

  28. Nice review Pakhi. Keep it up!

  29. rks ji ke darshan ke lie hum koson paar chale aaye 🙂

    Pakhi: Nice blog and good review 🙂

  30. I will definitely be visiting again, Pakhi. Would love to read more of your writings.

  31. Nice Review – Blog luks gud – gud work 🙂

  32. Hi pakhi. Good to see many members here.Good review but the film did not work.

  33. Hey pakhi,

    All the best for the blog. Ur writings deserve it!

    and wonerful review as alwys..u liked the movie this much i wish u had seen the original. or better, i wish the makers did stick to it..

  34. I came talked with people and we didn’t exchange any comment 🙂

  35. Are you talking to me or Hardik?

  36. well even we exchanged few comments.

  37. @PC – do I know you from NG?

  38. i am not on NG..bt i do read it time to time. our opinions match a lot! 😆

  39. Rks ab aap hamsein baat na karein usmi meri kya galti . ek bar apni smile de dena
    pata chal gaya aapka id kaunsa hai

  40. “i will not watch a katrina movie for 6 months but come on sb yaar ”

    Hardik you don’t even talk with me when I come in Fake ID. Pakhi atleast talks with me 🙂

  41. hi rks,so you are here.Are you vijay on NG sb?

  42. “Hardik you don’t even talk with me when I come in Fake ID. Pakhi atleast talks with me”

    fake id thing worked superbly with kunal so i avoid most of the fake ids. ab aap hamein koi hint dete to def baat karte . lekin pakhi se puchna padega aapke fake id ke barein me

  43. rks cannot be vijay . because vijay is a Man united fan and he is also present at redcafe.net

  44. hardik,vijay is my multiple id.Rks could have disabled it.That’s why I am asking.

  45. r u vijay at redcafe.net too ?

  46. It could be rks.Vijay has been disabled and taken over by rks,I think.

  47. no vijay is original id

    he goes to man united games , is on redcafe.net . he is definately a diff person.

  48. Hi Pakhi!

    Now that you have your own blog,would you plz disclose your sources of Kites here? 🙂

  49. Nice to see you active on your own blog.

  50. and nice to see you Som on Pakhi’s blog!!

  51. its a nice watchable movie…i liked especially the performance of irfan khan

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: